News Poll
 
Do you trust the current members of the City Council to do what's best for Gilroy?
Yes
No
Past Polls
   Top Opinion
 
   Opinion
 

 High-speed rail – so many questions, so few answers
Nov 19, 2009
 
 Letters: Tax and divert, spend and lie – when will voters scream 'Enough!'
Nov 19, 2009
 
  More Opinion...
   

OPINION > LISA PAMPUCH


Tough Questions That need answers in the wake of Katrina
Sep 6, 2005
 By Lisa Pampuch

It's heartbreaking to watch the despair, death and destruction that Hurricane Katrina has brought to the Gulf Coast. While hundreds of thousands of people try to cope with the life-altering consequences of the natural disaster, the catastrophe has ignited debate on unexpected fronts.

The War in Iraq. Life in storm-ravaged communities - sewage-fouled water, unburied corpses, no food, drinking water, medicine or shelter - has been compared to living in a war zone or a third-world country. The lawlessness - rape, sniper fire, arson, looting - that's erupted has been compared to the violence in Iraq. There's no small irony in that, as some have blamed the slow federal response, in part, on the deployment of so many National Guard troops in Iraq and the slashing of hurricane preparedness and flood control funds from the federal budget to pay for the war.

n Global Warming. Respected scientists say that while the hurricane can't be blamed on global warming, its intensity can. The waters in the Gulf of Mexico are warmer than they used to be, and warm water fuels hurricanes. These scientists say the increase in higher-intensity hurricanes over the last 30 to 50 years is a direct result of global warming. But like many conservatives, members of the Bush Administration have pooh-poohed global warming, just like many doubt evolution. It's interesting to note that many conservatives' positions on global warming and evolution are directly opposite to the positions most scientists take on these issues. When it comes to science matters, I'll continue to give more weight to what scientists, not politicians, say. After Katrina, I hope most voters will do the same.

Homeland Security/FEMA. Former Gilroy Mayor Mike Gilroy was surprised by the lack of disaster plans for "... a place that is ... under sea level..." Gilroy said he thought that "... you'd have a plan for a catastrophic hurricane ... just as the city of Gilroy has plans for a catastrophic earthquake." These are important, reasonable questions. The apparent lack of advance planning and slow federal response to Katrina has many people questioning the Bush Administration's decision to downgrade the Federal Emergency Management Agency from a cabinet-level agency and fold it into the new Department of Homeland Security. Debate about the wisdom of this move will undoubtedly continue and is a good thing.

Meanwhile, I wonder about the people in charge. Homeland Security Secretary Michael Chertoff said of those who did not leave after a mandatory evacuation order was issued, "Some people chose not to obey that. That was a mistake on their part." Setting aside the utter insensitivity of Chertoff's comment, it stuns me that Chertoff ignores or is ignorant of the fact that in the poverty-stricken regions of New Orleans, many people don't own cars, or if they do, can't afford to pay for several days, let alone weeks or months, in motel rooms. It's reasonable to wonder why a plan wasn't in place to evacuate those without the means to evacuate themselves.

Insurance. For me, the hurricane is a reminder of the arbitrary way the insurance industry treats natural disasters. Tornado, blizzard or hurricane? That'll be covered by your homeowner's insurance. Earthquake or flood? Sorry, those natural disasters require special insurance on top of your homeowner's insurance. I asked Rep. Richard Pombo about this when he met with the editorial board last week, and he said he's heard of a plan promoted by some real estate and building industry lobbyists to create a privately administered insurance pool for all natural disasters, but it has never gained traction in Congress. Here's hoping one positive effect of Katrina is reformation of the arbitrary system of homeowner's insurance coverage for natural disasters.

Blame or Accountability. I've heard people say now isn't the time to point fingers, now is the time to help the storm's victims. I say now is the time to do both. Once again, I'm reminded of the wisdom of Bill Maher's exhortation of the importance of holding two thoughts in one's head at the same time. Yes, now is the time to help the victims of Hurricane Katrina. Check Saturday's Dispatch for ways you can help locally, or just write as big a check as you can to the American Red Cross (www.redcross.org).

At the same time, we must also consider the important questions this catastrophe presents. Now is the time to evaluate what went wrong, to hold those responsible accountable and to harness our passion to make sure our government never fails its duty to citizens so dramatically ever again. Let's do it before the next congressional election, which is just 15 short months away.

Lisa Pampuch is a technical editor and a member of the newspaper's editorial board. She lives in Morgan Hill with her husband and two children. Reach her at lisapampuch@iname.com.


Lisa Pampuch
Lisa Pampuch is a technical editor and a member of the newspaper's editorial board. She lives in Morgan Hill with her husband and two children. You can reach her at lisapampuch@iname.com

POST A COMMENT

If you are under 13 years of age you may read this message board, but you may not participate. Here are the full legal terms you agree to by using this comment form.

blog comments powered by Disqus

Add to Google Add to My Yahoo!  Email This Article  Print
 Opinion: Lisa Pampuch
Columnist's NIMBYbess and numbskull marijuana logic
Nov 9, 2009
 
Belief in supernatural should never result in a child's death
Oct 26, 2009
 
Hopefully, the GOP will run Campbell not Whitman
Oct 12, 2009
 
Cheerleaders can't contend 'it's a sport' when convenient
Sep 28, 2009
 
 Opinion: Erika Mailman
Swine flu – it's just not that bad, but it's still scary
Nov 19, 2009
 
Deli, old-fashioned bakery, pocket park, wine bar, and so forth
Nov 5, 2009
 
Witchcraft family history spawns new take on Halloween
Oct 23, 2009
 
Downtown Gilroy: A treasure chest waiting to be unlocked
Oct 8, 2009
 
 Opinion: John Larson
School board's 3-hour meeting list – question is now what?
Nov 16, 2009
 
Tipping the scales on a 'Weed-Mart' in Gilroy
Nov 2, 2009
 
'Footloose' Gilroy style: the crux of the dancing issue
Oct 19, 2009
 
More Lisa Pampuch... More Erika Mailman... More John Larson...


 Obituaries

 Florence Jex Bowen
8/16/1909 - 11/8/2009

 Jack E Rocca
7/10/1917 - 11/14/2009

 Raymond Bustinza
9/9/1951 - 11/14/2009

 Raymond Ybarra Soto
4/28/1934 - 11/5/2009

 Elizabeth Sydney Pearson
12/26/1944 - 11/15/2009

 Frank Pancho Escudero
6/22/1942 - 10/30/2009

 Russell Rossi
4/21/1946 - 11/6/2009

 William (Bill) Sandoe Hanna, Jr.
2/23/1935 - 11/1/2009

 Larry Armel Graves
1/1/1946 - 11/9/2009

 Photos
News
     
Sports
     
Special Events
     
Full Pages
     
 Videos
Highlights from the 53rd annual Prune Bowl
Nov 17, 2009
 
Inside the pot shop
Nov 13, 2009
 
Care for some worm soup?
Nov 3, 2009
 
Dedicating a school to a dedicated man
Nov 3, 2009
 
 GilroyTV
 Most Wanted
 
More Obituaries... More Photos... More Videos...
Advertise | Contact Us | Subscriber Center | RSS Feed
Copyright © 2009 | MainStreet Media Group | All rights reserved.