News Poll
 
Should the Council vote to close City Hall to the public on non-furlough Fridays so employees can get their work done?
Yes
No
Past Polls
   Top Opinion
 
   Opinion
 

 Letters: Farmers urge residents: DO NOT protest groundwater charges
Mar 15, 2010
 
 End special treatment for the Catholic Church at VMC
Mar 15, 2010
 
  More Opinion...
   

OPINION > LISA PAMPUCH


Just the facts, please, about how newspapers work
May 25, 2009
 By Lisa Pampuch

"I want the news delivered unbiased. I thought that was the whole point with journalism."

~ Boondocks cartoonist Aaron MacGruder

In the seven-plus years that I've been writing a newspaper column, I've twice seen the need to offer a newspaper primer to my readers.

Sadly, I'm compelled to offer one a third time.

As a former newspaper reporter and editor and current columnist and editorial board member, I'm disheartened when I see how many people don't grasp the simple concepts that I'm about to review.

Some folks lament the decline of newspapers based on circulation numbers or reports of newspapers folding or moving to online-only editions. My lamentations are prompted by an upswing in signs that people don't seem to know - and worse, often don't seem to care - about newspaper basics. I place a lot of the blame on cable television news.

First, it's important to comprehend the difference between two types of content: news and opinion. News articles appear on the pages that don't have the word "Opinion" plastered in large letters across the top. They present an unbiased, factual accounting of events. The goal of news articles is to inform, not to sway opinion. Opinion pages, which feature that hard-to-miss "Opinion" label, contain editorials, columns, editorial cartoons and letters to the editor. The goal of most opinion content is to persuade, to compel readers to take a particular action. Editorials are opinion pieces that reflect the opinion of the majority of the editorial board. Columns (like this) and letters to the editor contain the author's opinion and analysis of current events.

Next, it's important to understand who writes what:

n Reporters write news articles.

n Opinion writers write letters to the editor, columns, and editorials.

A reporter aims to inform the community about important current events. Opinion writers aim to persuade. A letter writer might encourage residents to support a fund-raiser. The editorial board might remind readers of the dangers of drunk driving. A columnist might oppose a particular proposition.

I shake my head - frequently - every time some criticizes a column of mine by referring to me as a "reporter." I'm a columnist. It's a critical difference.

Because we live in the age of Fox News, which blurs - nay, obliterates - the line between news and opinion, many folks are confused about cable TV news content. But the local papers for which I write respect these boundaries, so there's really no excuse for their readers to have difficulty discerning the difference in the content that appears in their pages. Because, for example, television pundit Bill O'Reilly (imagine that, he's on Fox News) likes to call himself a "journalist" even though he makes his living spouting opinions, many folks are uncertain about roles in the cable television news realm. But the local papers for which I write do not confuse reporters and opinion writers, so their readers should not have difficulty making the important distinction.

Finally, a few final points that bear emphasis:

- Subjects of news stories and opinion pieces are introduced with their full name and then referred to by their last name throughout the rest of the article or column. This is not a matter of disrespect but of long-standing newspaper convention.

- Editors write headlines. They are not written by reporters, columnists, or letter writers. If you don't like a headline, direct your complaint to the editor.

- If you disagree with an opinion piece, don't accuse the writer of being misinformed because you come to different conclusions about the proper course of action or meaning of events. If the opinion writer has a fact wrong, it's fair to say she's misinformed. If an opinion writer's analysis of the facts is different than yours, it's only fair to say that she has a different set of priorities than yours.

- Disagreeing with someone's opinion does not constitute a personal attack. A personal attack is motivated by animus toward a particular individual. Differing opinions are caused by disagreements about priorities, leading people to dissimilar conclusions about the best course of action.

Understanding these basics will go a long way toward helping you derive more benefit and less heartburn from your local newspaper.

"Do not fear to be eccentric in opinion, for every opinion now accepted was once eccentric."

~ Philosopher Bertrand Russell


Lisa Pampuch
Lisa Pampuch is a technical editor and a member of the newspaper's editorial board. She lives in Morgan Hill with her husband and two children. You can reach her at lisapampuch@iname.com

POST A COMMENT

If you are under 13 years of age you may read this message board, but you may not participate. Here are the full legal terms you agree to by using this comment form.

blog comments powered by Disqus

Add to Google Add to My Yahoo!  Email This Article  Print
 Opinion: Lisa Pampuch
End special treatment for the Catholic Church at VMC
Mar 15, 2010
 
City Council's charge: get the most bang for our bucks
Mar 1, 2010
 
Critical thinking cures partisanship
Feb 16, 2010
 
Budgets, same-sex marriage, the end and the means
Jan 18, 2010
 
 Opinion: Erika Mailman
Collaboration vital to downtown
Mar 11, 2010
 
Changing the face of downtown one storefront at a time
Feb 25, 2010
 
In Gilroy, 'you can buy pot, but you can't dance downtown'
Feb 11, 2010
 
Playgrounds, parks under attack, city vigilance needed
Jan 28, 2010
 
 Opinion: John Larson
Are Gilroyans overly harsh in criticizing their own town?
Mar 9, 2010
 
Random thoughts from a real Gilroy columnist
Feb 22, 2010
 
Live well, retire in real style – get a government job
Feb 8, 2010
 
Doesn't understand parents who ignore safety and the law
Jan 25, 2010
 
More Lisa Pampuch... More Erika Mailman... More John Larson...


 Obituaries

 Mary Margret Ramsay
10/23/1931 - 3/12/2010

 Monnie (Ella) Phillips
7/23/1923 - 3/15/2010

 Josephine Greco
8/21/1911 - 3/12/2010

  Rose Velasco Jones
9/27/1919 - 3/5/2010

 Frances Lindeleaf
6/27/1920 - 3/9/2010

 Patricia Gough Risk
4/1/1920 - 3/8/2010

 Roy Benjamin Naylor, Jr.
10/13/1918 - 3/8/2010

 Beatriz Valdez Zertuche
2/11/1927 - 3/5/2010

 Hermie M. Medley
1/7/1920 - 2/28/2010

 Photos
News
     
Sports
     
Special Events
     
Full Pages
     
 Videos
Audio recording from Pentagon shooter
Mar 5, 2010
 
Yearning to teach, willing to learn
Mar 2, 2010
 
Red Phone: A congested intersection
Mar 2, 2010
 
One sweet ride
Mar 2, 2010
 
 GilroyTV
 Most Wanted
 
More Obituaries... More Photos... More Videos...
Advertise | Contact Us | Subscriber Center | RSS Feed
Copyright © 2010 | MainStreet Media Group | All rights reserved.