News Poll
 
Should the city enact a ban on the sale of fireworks that would go into effect beginning next year?
Yes
No
Past Polls
   Top Opinion
 
   Opinion
 

 'Hey, mom, that's really not my report card, honest …'
Jul 2, 2009
 
 Sadly, a GHS example of all that is wrong with high school athletics
Jul 2, 2009
 
  More Opinion...
   

OPINION > OUR VIEW


Police, fire employee benefits bankrupt Vallejo – Gilroy next?
Feb 29, 2008
 By Dispatch Editorial Board

Burgeoning public safety benefits are fast becoming a huge burden

Unless you're totally oblivious to regional news, you've by now heard the big news: The Bay Area city of Vallejo, population a little more than double that of Gilroy, is going broke.

Hundreds of media organizations have, of course, descended on Vallejo to report on something the Dispatch has been harping on for more than a decade - the exponential and outrageous burden being placed on communities by burgeoning public safety benefits.

Consider these bankruptcy-related messages:

Police and firefighter union contracts are breaking the bank

  • MediaNews: With the city of Vallejo on the brink of bankruptcy, 20 police and fire employees in the past three days have submitted their retirement papers and more are expected to follow, officials reported.

    The sudden exodus of public safety employees has officials worried about how well the departments will be able to serve the city.

  • Channel 10 News: The Solano County city of about 117,000 has a $6 million budget deficit and is projected to run out of money by the end of March, says City Manager Joe Tanner.

    Efforts to re-negotiate police and firefighter union contracts have broken down …

    Some cutbacks have already been instituted: only emergency 911 calls will receive an immediate response; trees are not being trimmed and park maintenance services have been reduced. City officials are considering layoffs and rotating closures of fire stations and libraries.

  • Vallejo Times Herald: Bankruptcy is certain to spark fresh debate about the cost of unfunded employee benefits, and the impacts on bond holders.

    As of December, the city had accrued a $135 million liability for the present value of retiree benefits earned by active and retired employees. Further, there is a $6 million added cost as current employees continue to vest and earn future benefits, the city said.

    "If bond holders are hurt by a bankruptcy, then future lenders will probably put constraints on elected officials' ability to make promises while in office that must be paid after they leave," said CPA Marcia Fritz, vice president and treasurer for California Foundation for Fiscal Responsibility, which advocates for pension reform.

    "It's almost a relief that it's finally coming to this in Vallejo because it will be an example of what happens when you've got a lot of people with their fingers in the cookie jar," she said. "I saw this coming years ago."

    … Experts agree one thing is certain. If the city cannot pay its employees because the general fund is dry … City Manager Joe Tanner must instruct all employees to stay home.

    Alan Davis, attorney for the police and fire unions whose leaders are negotiating with the city to erase an immediate $6 million shortfall, declined comment. The unions represent employees whose salaries total 80 percent of Vallejo's general fund.

It's not if Gilroy will face these same circumstances, but when

Unfortunately, the question for Gilroy is not if the city will face these dire circumstances, but when? In our town, the driving evil is binding arbitration for police and fire employees - passed by unsuspecting voters - and used by the unions to demand more and more lucrative benefits such as the 3 percent at 50 retirement plan. That works like this: Compensation for a retiree above age 50 with 30 years of service equals 90 percent of the average monthly pay rate for the last employment period of either 36 months or 12 months, depending on the employer's contract with CalPERS.

The burden of these plans is growing by leaps and bounds, and it's an unfair burden on our city.

Council members (dare we say gutless) fear the union smackdown at the polls and so, the city train heads for a financial head-on as we merrily try to build more retail to mask these unrelenting obligations.

Perhaps new City Manager Tom Haglund can put together a Gilroy bankruptcy intersection chart showing when we'll run out of cash. Maybe that will wake our local leaders up.

Act now:

Send an e-mail to Mayor Al Pinheiro at: Al.Pinheiro@ci.gilroy.ca.us

To understand how 3 @ 50 works, go to: www.porac.org/3percent@50.html


Dispatch Editorial Board
Got a question or a comment? Send us an email.

POST A COMMENT

If you are under 13 years of age you may read this message board, but you may not participate. Here are the full legal terms you agree to by using this comment form.

blog comments powered by Disqus

Add to Google Add to My Yahoo!  Email This Article  Print
 Opinion: Our View
Sadly, a GHS example of all that is wrong with high school athletics
Jul 2, 2009
 
City Council has a chance to lead by example and cut their benefits
Jun 29, 2009
 
Take a closer, second look before deciding to tear down youth center
Jun 25, 2009
 
Judges' voluntary pay cut a refreshing example of leadership
Jun 22, 2009
 
 Opinion: Letters to the Editor
Veteran grateful to this fine country for help in tough times
Jul 2, 2009
 
No compromise, no new taxes … the places to cut are very clear
Jun 29, 2009
 
Letters: Soak the taxpayer – showers and bike storage for library employees
Jun 25, 2009
 
Letters: Supports community garden and a temporary arts center
Jun 25, 2009
 
 Opinion: Cheers & Jeers
Chief hiring secrecy
Dec 7, 2007
 
Scary sexual predators
Nov 16, 2007
 
A fond farewell to Val
Nov 9, 2007
 
A fond farewell to Val
Nov 9, 2007
 
More Our View... More Letters to the Editor... More Cheers & Jeers...


 Obituaries

 Baltazar Jimenez Haro, Sr.
3/8/1923 - 7/1/2009

 David Narvaez, Jr.
10/27/1955 - 6/27/2009

 Raul M. Cesena
6/29/1935 - 6/28/2009

 David L. Yoder
6/23/1936 - 6/28/2009

 Louise C. Schulte
8/4/1914 - 6/27/2009

 Louie Anthony Valdez
2/10/1990 - 6/25/2009

 Victor Julian Rizzi
11/5/1948 - 6/24/2009

 James Edward Hults
9/20/1936 - 6/23/2009

 Raul Raymond Heredia
12/18/1968 - 6/23/2009

 Photos
News
     
Sports
     
Special Events
     
Full Pages
     
 Videos
Fire claims 58 hay bales, but homeowner protects home
Jun 24, 2009
 
Propane tank catches fire
Jun 24, 2009
 
Fatal crash on Highway 152
Jun 19, 2009
 
Goodbye Gilroy High School
Jun 17, 2009
 
 GilroyTV
 Most Wanted
 
More Obituaries... More Photos... More Videos...
Advertise | Contact Us | Subscriber Center | RSS Feed
Copyright © 2009 | MainStreet Media Group | All rights reserved.