News Poll
 
Would you pay a $5 toll to travel a new highway route to Highway 5 that bypassed Pacheco Pass?
No
Yes

This Is CAPTCHA Image
Enter numbers from above image:


Past Polls
   Top News
 
   Opinion
 

 Principles are key to good candidates
Sep 6, 2010
 
 Letters: Doing the right thing after a theft
Sep 6, 2010
 
  More Opinion...
   

NEWS > CITY AND GOVERNMENT


Rural residents oppose Highway 101 alignment for high-speed train
Feb 1, 2010
 By Jonathan Partridge

A map of some of the proposed routes through Gilroy. Click on photo for a larger version.
Photo by: Special to The Dispatch
Rural Gilroy residents showed up in droves to the Gilroy City Council meeting Monday to express their ire at a potential California High-Speed Rail route aligned with Highway 101 east of Gilroy.

The California High-Speed Rail Authority discussed various potential routes for the train during a study session, including a route that ran downtown, a route that ran adjacent to Highway 101 and a newly proposed route that ran further east of the highway.

More than 30 residents from rural areas north and east of Gilroy told California High-Speed Rail Authority officials that they should keep the train out of their neck of the woods.

"I am disturbed about this belief that if we can't make it work in the city of Gilroy, we'll just move it out to our country cousins," rural Gilroy resident Jeff Amstutz said.

The 800-mile California High Speed Rail system, expected to begin operations in 2020, is slated to have routes from San Diego to Sacramento and to the Bay Area, transporting passengers at speeds of up to 220 mph. A 123-mile stretch from Merced to San Jose would run through the Pacheco Pass with a proposed station in Gilroy. The entire rail project is estimated to cost $45 billion.

Monday's study session was one of several that high-speed rail authority officials have hosted in the Gilroy council chambers. However, it was the first study session to attract a large crowd from Gilroy's unincorporated areas.

Representatives from the California High-Speed Rail Authority showed a computer-animated presentation of various potential train routes, some of which elicited groans from many residents as they pointed to portions that would run near or through their homes. In particular a route that ran east of Highway 101 appeared to run less than 500 feet east of Carolyn Court and Garcia Lane and cut through property on a rural road off of Buena Vista Avenue.

Another route closer to Highway 101 crossed through properties south of Masten Avenue on Rucker, Denlo and Buena Vista avenues.

Separate downtown routes went through several industrial properties east of Monterey Street throughout Gilroy.

David Wemmer, an infrastructure engineering manager for the project, said the computer-animated routes that were displayed Monday are sure to change.

"These alignments are still in development," he said. "If you see a house by a colored line it may not end up by a colored line," he added, making reference to the colored routes that appeared on the projection screen.

Still, those words served as little consolation to most attendees.

"I'm appalled at what is going on and what is about to happen," rural Gilroy resident Yvonne Saucedo said. "It is going to happen in our lifetime, and it's terribly irresponsible."

Attendees applauded as various speakers expressed concern about the impact of the project on rural life. Many of them shook their heads as they looked at the animated route.

Mayor Al Pinheiro questioned Monday whether the cost of placing the train east of Gilroy would be substantially cheaper than running it through town. However, high-speed rail representatives indicated that would not be the case. Right-of-way costs only make up about 5 percent to 10 percent of the total project, they said, and moving the tracks to rural areas likely would only affect the cost by about 5 percent. By contrast, trenching the railroad tracks could increase the cost of the project by about 30 percent.

Councilman Bob Dillon, who has opposed the project from the very beginning, said that the California High-Speed Rail Authority ultimately would make a decision on the project route regardless of the council's desires.

Still, attendees said the council needed to do all that it could to make the project acceptable to Gilroy - and for them that meant keeping it out of the rural areas.

"I think if people who voted for this knew what it was going to be, they would not have voted for it," rural Gilroy resident Elaine Jelsema said.

Despite the tense reception toward the high-speed rail project, regional project manager Gary Kennerley said he was encouraged to see the large turnout.

"(The word) is getting out to the unincorporated area," he said.


Jonathan Partridge
Jonathan Partridge covers community issues for The Dispatch, including City Hall and public safety. Reach him at 847-7109 or e-mail him at jpartridge@svnewspapers.com.

POST A COMMENT

If you are under 13 years of age you may read this message board, but you may not participate. Here are the full legal terms you agree to by using this comment form.

blog comments powered by Disqus

Add to Google Add to My Yahoo!  Email This Article  Print
 News: City and Government
City of Gilroy posts 2009 employee compensation report
Sep 3, 2010
 
Gilroy open to providing salary information online
Sep 2, 2010
 
High-Speed Rail Authority's decision: Train will run through Gilroy
Sep 2, 2010
 
City, MediLeaf await judge's decision on whether to reopen dispensary
Sep 1, 2010
 
 News: Crime, Fire and Courts
Gilroy man arrested for repeated sexual assault of minor
Sep 8, 2010
 
Woman tries to walk out of Wal-Mart with $500 in groceries
Sep 8, 2010
 
Police Blotter
Sep 8, 2010
 
Gilroy Foods fire sends firefighter to hospital
Sep 8, 2010
 
 News: Schools
Eliot Elementary a soaring success
Sep 6, 2010
 
Trustees plan for fourth middle school
Sep 6, 2010
 
Morgan Hill principal under fire
Sep 2, 2010
 
School districts stand alone with seven-member boards
Aug 31, 2010
 
More City and Government... More Crime, Fire and Courts... More Schools...


 Obituaries

 Victor M. Monje
7/27/1946 - 9/4/2010

 Rosalie Ann Roy
4/3/1940 - 8/17/2010

 Thomas Furtado
5/27/1951 - 8/21/2010

 Shirley Mae Silva
6/23/1941 - 9/1/2010

 Carmen Lucy (Loera) Sanchez
1/16/1922 - 8/28/2010

 Jack Silos Armendariz
8/22/1938 - 8/29/2010

 Jack Silos Armendariz
8/22/1938 - 8/29/2010

 Frank J. Caliri
4/30/1930 - 8/27/2010

 Connie Olavarri Lopes
12/8/1920 - 8/24/2010

 Photos
News
     
Sports
     
Special Events
     
Full Pages
     
 Videos
Football - Christopher vs Sobrato 9/3/10
Sep 4, 2010
 
Opera singers give back
Aug 27, 2010
 
Volunteer Harvest
Aug 27, 2010
 
Gilroy Drug Bust: Neighbors shocked about meth lab
Aug 23, 2010
 
Gilroydining
 Most Wanted
 
More Obituaries... More Photos... More Videos...
Advertise | Contact Us | Subscriber Center | RSS Feed
Copyright © 2010 | MainStreet Media Group | All rights reserved.