News Poll
 
Should the city of Gilroy be paying to have four firefighters staff each engine, or are three firefighters enough?
Four
Three
Past Polls
   Top News
 
   Opinion
 

 Fire protection in Gilroy: The question is at what cost?
Nov 5, 2009
 
 Letters: Get the facts from the firefighters; City Council endangering public
Nov 5, 2009
 
  More Opinion...
   

NEWS > SCHOOLS


Grand jury finds flaws in schools' inventory control
Jun 29, 2009
 By Sara Suddes

A Civil Grand Jury report revealed that the Gilroy school district, Gavilan and many other school districts in the county aren't keeping good track of more than $300 million worth of inventory bought with taxpayer dollars.

"Lack of detailed attention towards inventory controls has exposed K-12 school districts and community college districts to potential security and financial risks," the report concluded. "Students cannot succeed without the proper support of technology and equipment. Therefore, districts should place an emphasis on controlling assets and avoid using funds to replace equipment that would be better spent supporting students' education."

About $288,000 in losses at a county school district due to suspected theft, fraud and administrative errors prompted the Santa Clara County Civil Grand Jury to examine how well each of the county's 33 school districts and four community college districts tracked their inventory. In many districts, including Gilroy Unified School District and Gavilan Joint Community College District, the results were not up to par.

"When proper controls are lacking, the school districts are subject to loss and theft of assets," according to the report. "Replacements of items would come from operating revenue, which is a waste of funds that should otherwise have been spent for planned teacher/student resources."

The Santa Clara County Civil Grand Jury is an investigatory body comprised of 19 citizens selected by the court to serve a one-year term. Their primary responsibilities are to serve as civil watchdog, to look into citizen complaints and to hear criminal investigations.

According to the report, K-12 trustees were unaware of their obligations under the law and had not been trained in inventory control and superintendents reported incomplete inventory information to their boards. In addition, districts failed to reconcile current inventories with past inventories, did not have board policies regarding inventory and did not track items over $500, as required by law. These problems persist in Gilroy and throughout the county, according to the report.

Although GUSD Superintendent Deborah Flores did not know how much money the district loses each year due to theft and inventory errors, she said her administration would take the Grand Jury's recommendations to heart. Flores was, however, surprised that the Grand Jury report expected superintendents and trustees to know the minute details of inventory practices. The business office is usually responsible for many of the duties outlined in the report and the newly appointed director of fiscal services will likely inherit many of the inventory obligations, Flores said.

Following the Grand Jury's recommendations shouldn't be too difficult, Flores said. The report advised GUSD to conduct inventory according to Education Code requirements at least once every two years, track each piece of equipment valued at more than $500 and implement a board policy outlining inventory practices.

"I think it will be easy to address - we just need a system to do it," Flores said.

Although it doesn't relate directly to inventory practices, the easiest recommendation to follow is one regarding approval of the superintendent's expenditures, Flores said. The Grand Jury found that superintendents' purchases in all districts were approved by subordinates. The Grand Jury recommended that these expenditures go through trustees for approval.

"The (Grand Jury) feels there is the potential for abuse," the report stated.

Like many other superintendents, Flores said she sticks to her budget.

"I'm not one of those people who buys extravagant furniture or goes to lots of conferences," she said. "I'm not sure why this is even an issue. It's a non-issue in our district."

Gavilan College President Steven Kinsella doesn't have a problem with the Grand Jury's recommendation either, said Gavilan spokeswoman Jan Bernstein Chargin.

"It's a good idea and doesn't cost anything," she said.

On the other hand, costly recommendations deserve closer scrutiny before being implemented, Bernstein Chargin said.

In the last five years, the college has lost or had stolen from it about $30,000 worth of equipment. But applying the Grand Jury's recommendation of tracking each item worth more than $1,000 - rather than the current practice of tracking items valued at more than $5,000 - could cost more than it saves, Bernstein Chargin said. A cost-benefit analysis will determine which recommendations Gavilan puts into effect, she said.

"The cost of doing what they're saying might not outweigh the savings," she said.

To read the entire grand jury report, click here


Sara Suddes
Sara Suddes covers education for the Gilroy Dispatch. Reach her at ssuddes@gilroydispatch.com or call (408) 847-7158.

POST A COMMENT

If you are under 13 years of age you may read this message board, but you may not participate. Here are the full legal terms you agree to by using this comment form.

blog comments powered by Disqus

Add to Google Add to My Yahoo!  Email This Article  Print
 News: Schools
Kids test new ways to fund science camp
Nov 5, 2009
 
Few checks for free lunch program
Nov 2, 2009
 
With live cougars and perfect weather, community celebrates new high school
Oct 31, 2009
 
Students not college-ready
Oct 29, 2009
 
 News: Community
Saint Louise to host seminar on affordable medication
Nov 6, 2009
 
A man on a mission
Nov 5, 2009
 
Elderly man gives up $1M in possible 'sweetheart scam'
Nov 5, 2009
 
Talented and thoughtful young man's life cut short
Nov 5, 2009
 
 News: Santa Clara County
South County gains permanent seat on VTA board
Nov 6, 2009
 
Well owner seeks $5 million refund from water district
Oct 29, 2009
 
Coe park cuts mean dirtier bathrooms, fewer camp patrols
Oct 28, 2009
 
H1N1 vaccine deliveries lag
Oct 28, 2009
 
More Schools... More Community... More Santa Clara County...


 Obituaries

 Ellen Rosemary Grundy
1/7/1946 - 10/31/2009

 Sadiee Frassetti
1/2/1919 - 11/2/2009

 Dorothy (Filice) Torre
7/14/1921 - 10/30/2009

 Julian Macias
1/28/1928 - 10/30/2009

 Kimberly Deanne Perry
1/11/1967 - 10/23/2009

 Marlene Ann Aza
12/23/1949 - 10/23/2009

 Archie B. Cole
8/13/1966 - 6/28/2009

 Manuel C. Lopez
2/8/1917 - 10/25/2009

 Jack B. Kazanjian
7/9/1923 - 10/23/2009

 Photos
News
     
Sports
     
Special Events
     
Full Pages
     
 Videos
Care for some worm soup?
Nov 3, 2009
 
Dedicating a school to a dedicated man
Nov 3, 2009
 
Revealing a history
Oct 27, 2009
 
It takes a village, and a choir
Oct 26, 2009
 
 GilroyTV
 Most Wanted
 
More Obituaries... More Photos... More Videos...
Advertise | Contact Us | Subscriber Center | RSS Feed
Copyright © 2009 | MainStreet Media Group | All rights reserved.