News Poll
 
Do you trust the current members of the City Council to do what's best for Gilroy?
Yes
No
Past Polls
   Top News
 
   Opinion
 

 High-speed rail – so many questions, so few answers
Nov 19, 2009
 
 Letters: Tax and divert, spend and lie – when will voters scream 'Enough!'
Nov 19, 2009
 
  More Opinion...
   

NEWS > CRIME, FIRE AND COURTS


Video evidence delays attempted murder case again
Sep 30, 2008
 By Chris Bone

If the people can't do it, might as well let the defense try.

So said Santa Clara County Deputy District Attorney Mark Hood Tuesday afternoon after he agreed, on behalf of the people, to let the attorney for Pete Joseph Valdez III - the man accused of trying to shoot a Gilroy police officer in the face - try to recover any potential video footage from Gilroy police.

Valdez briefly appeared at the Santa Clara County Superior Courthouse in San Martin today and will return 9 a.m. Oct. 31 along with his private attorney, Berndt Ingo Brauer, and any video evidence their side may have discovered from cameras in police cruisers that may or may not have been rolling that morning in November. Valdez could plead not guilty at his Halloween hearing and then the case would head into preliminary hearing, "but anything could happen," Hood said.

Four cars responded to the Nov. 15 incident, when officer John Ballard noticed Valdez, 29, bicycling about 3 a.m. without a headlight. When Ballard tried to stop him, Valdez took off. Ballard caught up with Valdez a few blocks later, and a foot chase ensued, police said. Valdez ultimately pointed a .25-caliber semiautomatic handgun loaded with seven hollow-point bullets at point blank range at Ballard's face before pulling the trigger repeatedly, police said.

The gun misfired, but Ballard's car did not have a camera inside to capture the event anyway, according to Sgt. Jim Gillio. Two of the cars that followed did have cameras, but they were not working correctly or were not being used at all, according to the city's IT Director, David Chulick. The fourth responding car did not have a camera. The police department is in the process of replacing the old, faulty equipment.

All this means video evidence probably does not exist, according to Gillio and Hood, the deputy district attorney. Even if one of the two cameras were rolling, police have said the incident likely took place out of frame or either before or after the other cars arrived.

But Brauer is not willing to risk anything, and Hood understands that, especially, he said, after Gilroy's IT team was unable to recover any potential video.

"I don't think there's anything to be found, but the defense just wants to make sure that there's not anything to be found," Hood said outside his office Tuesday. He added that Brauer and his team were trying to coordinate a time to come to the police station to fiddle with the video archives and see if they can find anything.

The difficulty in finding any footage began after the city's IT department moved physical video databases from the old police department to the new one sometime between Nov. 12 and Dec. 7, 2007. An employee removed some of the heavy disk drives from their shelving units to make their transportation easier, but that person did so without noting their specific order, which is vital because reinserting the drives out of order corrupts the data. The city has spent about $7,000 to identify the correct order, and since late July, Chulick has been looking for any Valdez footage.

"But we were told to hold off on it for now," Chulick said Tuesday. He explained that one of the drives was still not cooperating and that he had planned to send it off for further repair but was told to pause work and keep all the equipment on site, lest the drives get lost or further damaged during another trip.

The IT team's entire search stems partly from Superior Court Judge Hector E. Ramon's order last May for GPD to preserve all electronic information. Among a laundry list of requests before the preliminary hearing takes place, Brauer has also included the operation and maintenance histories of the department's cameras, permission to inspect the relevant vehicles and the hard drive that stored any potential videos along with the upkeep log for the storage device.

Valdez faces felony charges of attempted murder of a police officer, assault of a police officer with a firearm, being a felon in possession of a gun, and delaying or resisting a police officer. If convicted of these charges Valdez, who has been denied bail, would spend the rest of his life in prison.

In an interview with police after the incident, Valdez said he pulled the gun in hopes that an officer would shoot and kill him.

"I don't want to live," said a crying Valdez after he was apprehended, according to court records.

Valdez - the son of former 16-year Gilroy councilman Pete Valdez Jr. - has 10 prior convictions including three felony convictions for a strong-arm robbery.


Chris Bone
Chris Bone covers City Hall for The Dispatch. Reach him at 847-7109 or e-mail him at cbone@gilroydispatch.com.

POST A COMMENT

If you are under 13 years of age you may read this message board, but you may not participate. Here are the full legal terms you agree to by using this comment form.

blog comments powered by Disqus

Add to Google Add to My Yahoo!  Email This Article  Print
 News: Crime, Fire and Courts
Man pleads guilty to stabbing roommate below eye
3:25 PM
 
Ex-San Benito deputy faces minimum of 60 years in state prison
3:23 PM
 
Updated: 13-year-old raped, transients charged
Nov 19, 2009
 
Kidnap victim's mother calls for punishment of lying girl
Nov 19, 2009
 
 News: Schools
Convert South Valley and Brownell to charter schools?
3:00 PM
 
District: leverage stimulus funds to reduce special education budget
2:58 PM
 
Parents want El Roble gates locked after finding condoms, weapons on campus
11:51 AM
 
$4.6 million for GUSD from the feds
Nov 19, 2009
 
 News: Community
Salad fixins
Nov 19, 2009
 
Local media center wins regional awards
Nov 17, 2009
 
Gilroy's Army of altruists
Nov 16, 2009
 
Saint Louise limits visitor age in response to H1N1
Nov 13, 2009
 
More Crime, Fire and Courts... More Schools... More Community...


 Obituaries

 Florence Jex Bowen
8/16/1909 - 11/8/2009

 Jack E Rocca
7/10/1917 - 11/14/2009

 Raymond Bustinza
9/9/1951 - 11/14/2009

 Raymond Ybarra Soto
4/28/1934 - 11/5/2009

 Elizabeth Sydney Pearson
12/26/1944 - 11/15/2009

 Frank Pancho Escudero
6/22/1942 - 10/30/2009

 Russell Rossi
4/21/1946 - 11/6/2009

 William (Bill) Sandoe Hanna, Jr.
2/23/1935 - 11/1/2009

 Larry Armel Graves
1/1/1946 - 11/9/2009

 Photos
News
     
Sports
     
Special Events
     
Full Pages
     
 Videos
Highlights from the 53rd annual Prune Bowl
Nov 17, 2009
 
Inside the pot shop
Nov 13, 2009
 
Care for some worm soup?
Nov 3, 2009
 
Dedicating a school to a dedicated man
Nov 3, 2009
 
 GilroyTV
 Most Wanted
 
More Obituaries... More Photos... More Videos...
Advertise | Contact Us | Subscriber Center | RSS Feed
Copyright © 2009 | MainStreet Media Group | All rights reserved.